October 22, 2005
Shirley Holmes and Miss Watson and The Case of the Mr. Sylvester’s Disapearance
It was not a dark and stormy night when Shirley Holmes and Miss Watson drove up to a large victorian mansion at four-thirty in the afternoon. Fifteen minutes prior to there arrival they had received an urgent telephone call from Mrs. Norton, the house keeper, informing them that Mr. Sylvester was missing.
Shirley Holmes was, as you probably have guessed, a private detective and Miss Watson was her assistant. The two of them walked up the steps of the house and Shirley Holmes courageously rang the front doorbell.
The door was slowly swung open a few moments later by an ostentatious butler who asked them, “Didn’t you see the notice?”
“What notice?” Shirley Holmes said calmy while Miss Watson quickly looked around to make sure they hadn’t missed any quarantine signs.
The butler looked to the right and then back inside the room and then coughed slightly and picked something off a table that was just the the left of the door and placed it onto the door bell. It said, “Bell out of order, please knock.” Shirley Holmes knocked, despite the fact that the door was open and the butler said, “Won’t you come in?”
Not bothering to reply they entered and were soon met by Mrs. Norton, the housekeeper. She was almost in hysterics but calmed down enough to inform them all she knew about the situation, which was primarily that Mr. Sylvester had gone into his study around three in the afternoon and at three thirty she had gone in to bring him some tea and he wasn’t there.
“And, he’s not anywhere!” the housekeeper said as she broke into tears again.
The butler coughed slightly in a I-know-more-about-this-than-you-know-but-I-don’t-want-you-to-know-that-I-know-more-than-you-know-if-you-know-what-I-mean-and-I-hope-you-don’t sort of way and Watson became suspicious.
“You say he was in the study when last seen.” Shirley Holmes, who had noted everything but didn’t betray the fact said, “”Perhaps we should go there.
The housekeeper led the way and the butler followed at a discreet distance. When Mrs. Norton opened the door a house cat ran out but Miss Watson, who wasn’t paying as much attention to the matter as Shirley Holmes was didn’t notice this and promptly stepped on the cat’s tail. The cat promptly yowled and scratched Miss Watson very hard and Miss Watson promptly made a rather loud noise.
This didn’t seem to disturb Shirley Holmes’s concentration on the scene of the alleged disappearance and she had already noticed that the windows were easily operable and on the ground floor and that everything in the room was scrupulously clean which made the desk rather stand out, for it had a bit of clutter on it, clutter which required careful observation.
“Was Mr. Sylvester a neat man?” Shirley Holmes quickly asked.
“No, he was always untidy.” the housekeeper said in a way as though to mean that if he wasn’t her job would be a lot easier but that she didn’t mind his being untidy because it gave her something to do, “I have to clean this room every day, he always takes things out but never puts them away.”
“And when do you clean this room?” Shirley Holmes said, a clever hypothesis already formed in her unfathomable mind.
“Oh everyday at two-thirty!” the housekeeper promptly said.
“Have you found out something?” Miss Watson said eagerly.
“Yes, I believe I have encountered an important clue. If the housekeeper cleaned the room at two thirty then obviously whatever is on this table was put there since and therefore must be clues in the disappearance of Mr. Sylvester”
Everyone paused to take in the brilliance of this deduction and then Shirley Holmes proceeded, “What we see before us are only a few objects but their meaning is important. What do we see?” Shirley Holmes said, but Miss Watson knew by the way she said it that she didn’t want an answer since she was going to answer the matter herself.
“Here is a spoon,” Holmes said, pointing to the object and not touching or disturbing the scene of the crime, “and here is a bottle of olive oil, opened and partially empty, and here is a box of band aids that is opened and here is an empty band aid wrapper beside the box and here is a newspaper opened up on the advertisements page.”
“What do you deduce from this?” Miss Watson said eagerly after a suitable period of time had passed for allowing the mastermind to come to a conclusion.
“Well, quite obviously Mr. Sylvester used a band aid, but why? And when? Before he poured out a teaspoon of olive oil or after?”
“He poured out a teaspoon of olive oil! How did you figure that out?” Miss Watson said, quite excited for this had escaped her notice.
“Elementary, my dear Miss Watson. As you can see there is a slight residue on the spoon and since there the bottle of olive oil is the only liquid substance on the table and since if there was another substance to be poured Mr. Sylvester probably wouldn’t have put it away therefore we are left with the Olive Oil. And Miss Watson, your leg is bleeding.”
Miss Watson, who had forgotten this fact looked down at her leg and say that it was indeed bleeding and the housekeeper, now being aware of the fact quickly took a band aid from the box and it was applied and fit perfectly over the scratch marks. Miss Watson explained about the cat and the housekeeper said, “Yes, Lulu Belle always does scratch when her tail is stepped on, poor thing, but sometimes it’s so hard to see her.”
“I have it!” Shirley Holmes said looking very pleased.
“You know where Mr. Sylvester is already?” Miss Watson said, looking enormously pleased.
“Not quite yet, but I do know what happened. On entering the room, or sometime after that event, Mr. Sylvester stepped on the tail of the aforementioned cat and was rather upset about it, especialy when he was scratched. He took out the box of band aids and put one on over the scratch he had gotten and sat down. Looking at today’s newspaper he read on page three an article about how olive oil can increase the shine of a cat’s coat and decided to try it since it would make the cat more visible. So after pouring out a teaspoon full of olive oil and giving it to the cat he then sat down again and…” at that moment Shirley Holmes, who had been going through the motions of what probably had happened, sat down and took up the newspaper and after studying it for a moment said, “And noticed this advertisement.”
“How did you deduce that?” Miss Watson said.
“Because the article is circled in red ink and their is an ink pen with that sort of ink lying right here on the desk.”
“And what is it an advertisement for?” was the question just about everybody either asked or wanted too when at that moment the question was answered by hearing the door open and footsteps in the hall. In a moment Mr. Sylvester himself showed up and said, “Look Mrs. Norton! I just bought snake-bite-proof army boots! The man I bought them from assured me that they’d work against cat scratches too!”
“Just as I thought.” Shirley Holmes said.
“Congratulations Holmes!” Miss Watson said, “You’ve done it again!”
MORAL: It is usually a good idea to avoid stepping on the tail of a cat if you do not wish to be scratched. Also you might want to make sure that somebody is really missing before calling the police or private detectives. And sometimes, it actually is an advantage to be messy…







